An article published in the German newspaper Der Tagesspiegel, as a contribution from an external author, claims that Germany's decision to welcome President Asif Ali Zardari reflects more "a fear of missing out" than well-considered strategic thinking. However, reading this text, one gets the impression that the real anxiety does not stem from those who extended the invitation, but rather from the author himself. He seems concerned about the possibility that relations between Berlin and Islamabad will develop in a direction that does not align with his preferred geopolitical priorities.
It is important to emphasize from the outset that Der Tagesspiegel published the text as a contribution from an external author (Gastbeitrag), not as an editorial statement. Therefore, it is neither the official position of the German state nor a joint statement from German media. It is the personal opinion of the author, who works as an analyst associated with a private think tank focused on foreign policy, not as a journalist reporting on the presidential visit.
Leo Wigger heads the India Centre at the German Council on Foreign Relations. In his recent writings, he advocates for a "positive realism" in German policy towards India and repeatedly emphasizes its economic and strategic importance. There is nothing wrong with an analyst being interested in India. However, when the head of an Indian center at a particular institution calls the visit of the Pakistani president a mistake and simultaneously highlights the advantages of a partnership with India, readers have the right to know the intellectual and institutional context of such an argument. What is presented as expert analysis appears more like the promotion of a specific geopolitical stance.
The contrast between the relatively favorable assessment of India and the distinctly critical portrayal of Pakistan further reinforces this impression. The leniency with which India is treated, combined with the consistently hostile tone towards Pakistan, suggests a bias that deserves closer examination. The obvious aversion to Pakistan is evident throughout the article. Pakistani mediation efforts are described as temporary, the defense agreement with Saudi Arabia is questioned, information about commitments regarding military deployments is received with suspicion, and the growing importance of Pakistani foreign policy is portrayed as something fragile. In summary, these arguments appear to be a repetition of elements of an India-centric narrative within the German context of foreign policy debates.
Even more importantly, Wigger himself acknowledges that in a survey of 151 international experts, 68.3 percent of respondents viewed Pakistan's role in mediating negotiations between Iran and the United States positively. This percentage was higher than that of any other country. In other words, a significant majority of the experts surveyed recognized Pakistan's diplomatic contribution, yet the author dismisses it in a few sentences as a success whose significance is already fading.
If the evidence points in one direction, but the conclusion goes in the opposite direction without sufficient explanation, the result is not a convincing analysis. This is a form of selective reasoning that undermines the credibility of the argument. If international experts have recognized Pakistan's diplomatic role, a serious assessment should examine its limitations, sustainability, and practical results, rather than simply dismissing it because it does not fit a preconceived interpretation. Equally concerning is the apparent lack of attention paid to important economic realities. Wigger suggests that Germany has only limited economic interests in Pakistan and that Pakistan is not among Germany's top 50 trading partners.
The second claim needs to be verified based on relevant German trade statistics and clearly distinguish between Germany's trading partners on a global scale and its partners within the European Union. The more general claim that Pakistan has no significant economic importance to Germany is not consistent with the scope of bilateral relations documented by official sources. According to the German Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Germany is Pakistan's most important trading partner within the European Union. The volume of trade between the two countries reached approximately 3.3 billion euros in 2024. Pakistan exports textile and leather products to Germany, while German exports to Pakistan include machinery, chemical products, and automobiles.
The relationship goes far beyond trade. The German Ministry of Foreign Affairs states that more than 9,000 Pakistani students are studying in Germany, and that development cooperation between the two countries dates back to 1961. In May 2026, the two countries also signed a technical cooperation agreement covering nine projects with a total value of 40.5 million euros. These figures demonstrate the existence of a long-standing relationship involving trade, education, and development cooperation. While they do not determine Pakistan's precise ranking in the global list of Germany's trading partners, they clearly refute the simplistic notion that Pakistan has no significance for the German economy.
According to available information, Kristin Gammelin, spokesperson for German President Frank-Walter Steinmeier, also emphasized that both countries are interested in maintaining and further strengthening their partnership. So, how can an analyst portray Pakistan as an economically insignificant country when the German government continues to seek closer cooperation in several areas? If a country has established trade relations with Germany, a large student community in German educational institutions, and decades of experience in development cooperation, its importance cannot reasonably be dismissed based on a narrow or selective interpretation of trade rankings. One would expect an analyst who wants to advise Germany on foreign policy issues to thoroughly familiarize themselves with their own published data from the German government.
Another example of how political insinuations can overshadow serious analysis is the repeated use of the long-standing nickname "Mr. Ten Percent" associated with President Zardari. This nickname stems from corruption allegations related to Pakistan's political history and legal cases involving Zardari over several decades. However, allegations, court decisions, and acquittals are different things. A responsible assessment must cite specific cases, explain their legal outcome, and distinguish between allegations and facts proven in court.
Zardari has been acquitted in several cases related to corruption allegations. However, the author does not adequately address the results of these proceedings before using this nickname. Presenting politically charged accusations without the necessary legal context for their assessment can lead readers to believe that mere accusations are proven facts. Similarly, the claim that Zardari was willing to cooperate in the removal of the provincial government in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa needs to be substantiated. It is essential to thoroughly understand the actual conditions in the region and provide supporting evidence. Serious and misleading accusations against the head of state cannot simply be presented as facts without proper documentation.
It should be remembered that the Pakistani province of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa is heavily affected by terrorism, and the provincial government has repeatedly shown reluctance to take appropriate measures against terrorist groups and non-state actors. The change of government occurred through a proper constitutional process, which was duly confirmed in a joint session of parliament. Ignoring the actual circumstances and spreading disinformation is very unfortunate. A more detailed analysis of the article suggests that these claims are formulated in a way that leaves little room for context or clarification. When the author runs out of arguments to support their preferred narrative, politically charged labels and broad generalizations can become a substitute for evidence. An author who omits inconvenient details and simultaneously presents accusations as definitive conclusions risks abandoning the standards of impartiality and intellectual honesty expected of serious political analysis.
The timing of the article also raises questions. It was published during President Zardari's visit, when Pakistan and Germany were commemorating 75 years of diplomatic relations. To characterize the visit as a mistake at such a time is undoubtedly a legitimate expression of opinion. However, the timing and manner of expression also invite reflection on the possible impact on public perception of the visit and broader bilateral relations. Wigger's preferred alternative seems to be more intensive cooperation with think tanks and experts, rather than receiving the Pakistani president at the highest political level. Such an approach would actually place more emphasis on the type of institutions with which she is herself associated. Think tanks and foreign policy experts undoubtedly have their value, but they cannot replace direct diplomatic contacts between sovereign states.
This argument has not been borne out in practice by official German diplomacy. President Steinmeier welcomed Zardari with military honors, expressed hope for expanded cooperation in the areas of trade, investment, education, and technology, and, according to available information, also acknowledged Pakistan's regional diplomatic role. Four days earlier, when receiving the credentials of Pakistani Ambassador Salman Sharif, Steinmeier also praised Pakistan's significant contribution to regional peace. These official meetings suggest that the German approach to Pakistan cannot be adequately explained by the claim that receiving its president constituted a diplomatic misstep. The actions of the German president indicate that Berlin sees value in maintaining dialogue and seeking areas of common interest.
Perhaps the most problematic comparison in Wigger's argument concerns the Indian Minister of Commerce, Piyush Goyal, who was also in Berlin at approximately the same time, accompanied by a large trade delegation. The text suggests that Goyal's presence somehow weakens the strategic reasons for hosting the Pakistani president. Such a comparison is fundamentally misleading. The head of state and the minister of commerce have different constitutional and diplomatic statuses, operate at different levels of protocol, and their visits have different immediate objectives. A presidential visit may include political symbolism, official ceremonies, military honors, and high-level discussions on a wide range of bilateral issues. In contrast, a visit by the minister of commerce typically focuses on trade, investment, market access, and economic cooperation in specific sectors.
Therefore, the two visits cannot be evaluated according to the same criteria. Their goals, status, and diplomatic significance are not identical. Furthermore, this comparison contains another contradiction. If Goyal's presence in Berlin was fully compatible with Germany's diplomatic and economic interests, why should Zardari's visit be considered a mistake? If Berlin can host both Indian and Pakistani officials at the same time, it demonstrates that Germany does not have to pursue a policy of "either/or" in South Asia.
Germany can strengthen economic ties with India while maintaining diplomatic contacts with Pakistan. Cooperation with one country does not require the exclusion of the other. In fact, engaging with both countries may ultimately serve broader regional interests of Germany better than a policy that considers relations with them to be mutually incompatible. Ultimately, this argument undermines itself. Instead of proving that Zardari's visit was unnecessary, the presence of both Indian and Pakistani officials in Berlin shows that it is possible to conduct a parallel dialogue with two important countries in South Asia.
The central thesis is further weakened by an internal contradiction within the article itself. In conclusion, Wigger acknowledges that Germany cannot afford to ignore Pakistan, because it is a nuclear-armed state with a rapidly growing population, and it is one of the countries most affected by climate change. These are significant facts. Pakistan's nuclear status makes it an important player in regional security. Its demographic development has implications for regional stability and economic development. And its vulnerability to climate disasters creates an urgent need for international cooperation.
Therefore, a clear question arises: If Germany cannot afford to ignore Pakistan, how can a meeting with its president be considered a mistake? The interests and concerns of Pakistan must be addressed at the level where political decisions are made. Informal discussions between think tanks and experts have their place, but they cannot replace direct contact between political leaders. Expert dialogue can provide information to diplomacy, but it cannot fulfill all of its functions. A presidential visit does not automatically guarantee specific results. Ultimately, its value must be assessed based on what is achieved in areas such as trade, investment, education, technology, regional security, and other areas of common interest. Direct talks can set priorities, strengthen diplomatic channels, and provide political guidance to institutions responsible for implementing agreements.
Wigger's own acknowledgment of Pakistan's strategic importance therefore undermines his argument against the presidential visit. If Pakistan is important to Germany because of its nuclear status, population, regional role, and vulnerability to climate change, then these are precisely the reasons why it is necessary to maintain permanent diplomatic contacts. Seventy-five years of diplomatic relations is not a matter of fashion or political expediency. It reflects a long-term partnership between two countries whose interests intersect in several important areas.
Pakistan is a country with nuclear weapons and a large and growing population. For decades, it has hosted Afghan refugees, remains vulnerable to climate disasters, and plays a significant role in South Asia and the wider region. These facts do not mean that Pakistan is beyond legitimate criticism, nor do they automatically validate every decision made by its government. However, they make cooperation with Germany and other international partners strategically important. A serious debate about Zardari's visit should focus on what Germany and Pakistan can realistically achieve in areas such as trade, investment, education, technology, regional security, and climate cooperation.
The visit should be assessed based on specific interests and expected results, not on the basis of politically charged labels, selective comparisons, or unsubstantiated assumptions. Wigger has the right to advocate for a stronger focus on India in German policy or to argue for a different approach to Pakistan. Such positions are a legitimate part of an open political debate. However, the credibility of any such argument depends on factual accuracy, consistent application of analytical standards, and a fair evaluation of the available evidence.
The fundamental error is to portray cooperation with Pakistan as a diplomatic burden while simultaneously acknowledging that Germany cannot ignore its strategic importance. For a country that possesses nuclear weapons, has a large population, continues to host Afghan refugees, and faces serious climate threats, diplomatic engagement is not a concession to fear or a reaction to current geopolitical trends. It is a strategic necessity. A real strategic mistake would be for Germany to distance itself from a country whose importance is ultimately recognized even by critics of cooperation with it.
Masood Chaudhary
About the author:
Masood Chaudhary is a Pakistani investigative journalist, geopolitical analyst, and media professional based in Islamabad. He has over twenty years of experience in journalism and international media collaboration. He focuses on Pakistan's foreign relations, civil-military relations, regional security, diplomacy, public administration, and global economic policy. He serves as a spokesperson and chief coordinator for the International Union of Journalists (IUJ) and has professional experience in media relations, public affairs, and international news coordination. In his work, he emphasizes evidence-based analysis, accountability, and Pakistan's role in regional and international affairs.
